Achieving Slow Running

dgt

STEAM
It has been suggested in an article by John Rogers in Garden Rail (198) that by restricting the exhaust a loco can be prevented from 'running away' without reducing pulling power at low speed.
Has anyone experience in attempting this? Whilst the article refers to Mamods, this principal should apply equally to any steamer.

Dave.
 
Not sure on this but i found the secret was adjusting the cut off if you have walscherts gear. I could then successfully run manually down hill.

Your suggestion sounds correct in principle but never tried it.
 
CoggesRailway said:
Not sure on this but i found the secret was adjusting the cut off if you have walscherts gear. I could then successfully run manually down hill.

Your suggestion sounds correct in principle but never tried it.

The number of 16mm locos with Walshaerts is however, vanishingly small. I know that DJB provide a mod to alter the Accucraft Countess to full Walschaerts.
 
Hi Dave
Yes - restricting the exhaust can improve slow running and reduce the running away effect. It was popular om Mamods, many years ago, and I used a restrictor valve (exhaust regulator) on my Cheddar Iver with some success. This loco has a huge chimney so I was able to fit a proper valve in there. The downside was that it was completely silent. Needless to say I binned the valve and fitted a chuffer many moons ago. I now get the control from using 2.4ghx.
On Accucraft radio control locos with a reversing valve, you can get the same effect by using partial forward gear and then driving on the regulator. I have to admit that I didn't believe this until Rob Bushill demonstrated it to me. The downside, again, is reduced chuff and, of course it is not much help if your loco is manual.
I hope this helps
Cheers
Chris
 
while certaily a neophyte as far as live steam
this is what i think i have learned so far-and i could be very wrong-but so far it works for me

i have had great success with performance at low speeds -all things considered -ie load and flat track, outside temp-

by simply adjusting the fire-i run about 65%-80% of full open, and also , at least on the frant s, i am judicious about the water bath for added pressure-i get longer runs by far

on my #24 SRRL R/C roundhouse, which i can sorta get to crawl if Im simply not too hamfisted with the joy stick,
i simply never wait until blow off, and once heated -which in turn comes into the cab and heats the old style roof/ceiling mounted tank, increasing gas pressure , i back off the gas valve just a bit-which on my engine lowers the jet engine whine of the air intake/jet adjustment a bit

and it really helps-not only with throttle adjustment control

but also with an efficient use of water and thermal efficiency of fuel in heating the boiler

-i understand that a gentle heat up is actually better than a full blast, as the loco itself also must absorb the heat and when this is lower it is more efficient as more of the usable heat is taken rather than going up the stack -

-ie you dont get as much waste, blow off, etc
you have to find the equilibrium between load, grade and firebox rate

its sort of a trial and error process to learn but i am often able to run really slowly, like scale 5-8 mph
 
Back
Top