Live steam and DC track power

Robert Howard

Registered
Hi All,

I am aware that conventional wisdom is that running live steam interferes with using track power, but I am wondering if anyone on the forum does this and if they have any hint and tips on making it work?

I would guess a dedicated siding for steaming up is a good start.

Just wondering if I take the plunge on live steam if I will also need to convert my electric locos to battery power...

Cheers

Rob
 
Are you in to relaxation or agro?
Don't know how old you are but do you really want a new toddler on the scene?
Stick to track power!!!!!.
 
I've heard it alleged to be a problem. In the last 8 years experience of running (admittedly occasionally) a live steamer, and having visiting live steam, on a line that is normally electrically powered using dc (not digital), I have had no problems and no conflicts mixing the two.

Edit: you mention a dedicated siding for live steam. I don't bother, but I can see the attraction, as steaming up takes a little time and so being away from the rest of the action is worthwhile if you have the space.
 
I have run both, DC and Live Steam, together quite happily for the past 7 years on my layout. Just make sure your live steam locos and any stock you buy specifically to run with them have insulated wheels if you are going to run them at the same time as the track powered stuff. There is a show layout that does the rounds that mixes DCC and live steam. Most modern product from the likes of Accucraft, Roundhouse, etc' are fitted with insulated wheel-sets.

You might wish to convert track powered locos to battery in the future for other reasons, usually to get out of cleaning the track periodically or due to long term electrical conductivity issues, if you haven't done to right prep work prior to assembling your layout.
Max.
 
Hi Rob. I run both track power and live steam, and both at the same time with no problems. Though these days it's mostly live steam and battery power when my girls want to run there track power trains there was no more track cleaning needed than when we run solely track power. Now there are a couple of provisos to this, and like anything that makes life interesting there is no "one size fits all", and long may life be that way :)

Firstly our railway is under trees and we have always have problems at times maintaining good conductivity due to insect "honey dew" (droppings) and nectar from the trees, so I have always wiped the track down with a damp thin sponge cloth wrapped around a piece of wood before any running session. And I generally still do this even before a live steam session so therefore there is never a lot of build up of any oil or other deleterious material on the track.

Secondly some live steamers are more generous with dropping steam oil on the track than others. My Regner is quite frugal on steam oil, dropping very little, my Accucraft Plantation is not to bad but my Accucraft Leader is very messy at start up. I have had a couple of Roundhouse Lady Anne loco visit and they would be on a par with the Plantation. Having a steam up bay where they can clear condensate, which is the messiest time, would be a great help.

Finally don't over oil your steamies running gear. I have seen one chap being very heavy handed with lubricating and there was some problems after than loco. But long term over oiling his loco won't do it any good either!

So I'd say go for it, but yes you may well need a little bit more work on maintaining track cleanliness than solely track power. But oh the smell and sight of steam - well worth the effort for me :D
 
I run both , just clean the track as you normally would for DC operation, no problem at all 8)
 
Back
Top