Yes indeed it does sound odd an LGB loco being weak on the haulage front, that train shown causing issues would likely not phase a Stainz with only 1 motor, 4 wheels and just 1 traction tyre.I wonder if a weight was removed, to make 'room' for a decoder, perhaps?
PhilP
The centre axle is mainly hidden behind the bogie side frames and is not noticeable unless you look closely for the missing wheels.This is very good advice. Going to do some more tests with my other which isn't brilliant either. Does it visually affect the look having the central axle removed?
In the past there have been articles in smaller scales for such measuring devices. Mostly they used a spring type measure of the type used by fishermen, but these days there are similar devices used for pre weighing luggage to not get caught out by cheepo airlines minimal weight allowances. I just looked and sundry digital options for bag weighing available on Amazon sub £10. One of these attached to a coupling one end and an immovable object the other could I am sure make a usable device. Tractive effort would be measured in Kilo’s or Pounds. A Stainz would give a good starting point.The centre axle is mainly hidden behind the bogie side frames and is not noticeable unless you look closely for the missing wheels.
When I was investigating the pulling power, I didn't have a weighing device to actually measure the tractive efforts of my White Pass locos, modified and un-modified compared to my LGB F7 that pulls well. It would have been useful to have that data to show the improvement. If you have a way of measuring the tractive effort that would be useful.
Alan
Yep, I was thinking the same.In the past there have been articles in smaller scales for such measuring devices. Mostly they used a spring type measure of the type used by fishermen, but these days there are similar devices used for pre weighing luggage to not get caught out by cheepo airlines minimal weight allowances. I just looked and sundry digital options for bag weighing available on Amazon sub £10. One of these attached to a coupling one end and an immovable object the other could I am sure make a usable device. Tractive effort would be measured in Kilo’s or Pounds. A Stainz would give a good starting point.
Indeed so, needs to be on a G scale level track with no curves to get a fair comparison for us. Even then a pull of say 1kg would not mean much to compare a line with R1’s no grades compared to mine with 4ft rad curves and predominantly Peco points but general grades around 1:48.Yep, I was thinking the same.
I think the main issue is that the results are comparative rather than empirical - in other words a pull of so many kgs on a given spring scale won't necessarily be the same on someone else's track with someone else's scale.
A lengthman’s work is never finished.Bank Holiday Heritage service.... Accompanied by yet more ballasting and packing.View attachment 314167View attachment 314168View attachment 314169View attachment 314170View attachment 314171View attachment 314172View attachment 314173View attachment 314174View attachment 314175View attachment 314176View attachment 314177View attachment 314178View attachment 314179View attachment 314180View attachment 314181
Thanks. It also sounds good when a train passes over now, with metal wheels. Sounds level crossingy...Much better!